In a 2023 interview, director Mike Elliott stated: “We’d love to do Girls’ Rules 2*. The cast is up for it. But Universal is waiting to see how the nostalgia wave hits Gen Z.”* As of late 2025, no sequel has been greenlit. However, a new American Pie theatrical film (unrelated to the Presents series) has been rumored, potentially uniting original cast members.
★★½ (out of 5) Best for: Fans of the Presents series, The Sex Lives of College Girls , or anyone who wondered what American Pie would look like from the girls’ bathroom. american pie presents girls rules 20202020
It also updates the franchise’s approach to consent and agency. The girls aren’t just reacting to boys’ schemes; they’re driving the plot. In a 2023 interview, director Mike Elliott stated:
American Pie Presents: Girls’ Rules is a 2020 direct-to-video sex comedy film directed by Mike Elliott. It serves as the fifth and final installment in the American Pie Presents spin-off series and the ninth installment in the overall American Pie franchise. Notable for being the first film in the franchise to feature a female-centric narrative and an almost entirely female principal cast, the film attempts to modernize the brand’s formula by flipping the gender dynamics of the original 1999 classic. Released on DVD, Blu-ray, and Digital by Universal Pictures Home Entertainment, the film received generally negative reviews from critics and audiences, cited for its lack of the original’s charm and reliance on formulaic tropes. However, a new American Pie theatrical film (unrelated
Unlike previous spin-offs (like Band Camp or The Naked Mile ), Girls' Rules shifts the perspective. The story follows a group of high school senior girls—Annie, Kayla, Michelle, and Stephanie—who make a pact to help each other lose their virginities before graduation. But it’s not just about sex; it’s about power, friendship, and turning the tables on the boys who usually call the shots.
Their plans are thrown into chaos when a handsome new student, Grant (Darren Barnet)